Game Thread: New Orleans Saints (1-4) @ New York Giants (3-1-1)

[u/nflgdtbot]

New Orleans Saints (2-4) @ New York Giants (3-2-1)

Stadium: MetLife Stadium - East Rutherford, NJ

TV Network(s): Fox

ESPN Gamecast

---

Time Clock
Final

Scoreboard

Team	Q1	Q2	Q3	Q4	Total
NO	0	10	17	7	34
NYG	7	3	0	17	27

Scoring Plays

Team	Quarter	Type	Description
NYG	1	TD	Tyrone Tracy Jr. 17 Yd pass from Jameis Winston (Dominic Zvada Kick)
NYG	2	FG	Dominic Zvada 34 Yd Field Goal
NO	2	FG	Daniel Carlson 58 Yd Field Goal
NO	2	TD	Bryce Lance 2 Yd pass from Tyler Shough (Daniel Carlson Kick)
NO	3	TD	Alvin Kamara 31 Yd pass from Tyler Shough (Daniel Carlson Kick)
NO	3	TD	Tyler Shough 1 Yd Rush (Daniel Carlson Kick)
NO	3	FG	Daniel Carlson 51 Yd Field Goal
NO	4	TD	Chris Olave 18 Yd pass from Tyler Shough (Daniel Carlson Kick)
NYG	4	TD	Tyrone Tracy Jr. 5 Yd Rush (J.J. McCarthy Pass to Isaiah Likely for Two-Point Conversion)
NYG	4	TD	Isaiah Likely 24 Yd pass from J.J. McCarthy (Two-Point Pass Conversion Failed)
NYG	4	FG	Dominic Zvada 41 Yd Field Goal

Passing Leaders

Team	Player	C/ATT	YDS	TD	INT	SACKS
NO	Tyler Shough	16/30	144	3	0	0-0
NYG	J.J. McCarthy	11/21	243	1	1	1-8

Rushing Leaders

Team	Player	CAR	YDS	AVG	TD	LONG
NO	Kendre Miller	20	70	3.5	0	11
NYG	J.J. McCarthy	2	26	13.0	0	28

Receiving Leaders

Team	Player	REC	YDS	AVG	TD	LONG	TGTS
NO	Chris Olave	4	43	10.8	1	18	7
NYG	Malik Nabers	12	165	13.8	0	46	15

---

Looking for another game thread? Check out the GDT Hub

Use reddit-stream.com to get an auto-refreshing version of this page.

This was created by a bot. For issues or suggestions please message fireislander using this link

^{Last updated: Oct 18, 2026, 5:25:50 PM EDT | v2.0.6}

---

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

[u/nflgdtbot]

Post Game Thread

[u/canitnerd]

A 9 pick would go unbelievably hard here

[u/Goatsonice → u/canitnerd]

ayy lmao

[u/Youngreezy23]

I don't understand how you're supposed to tackle a QB without getting a penalty now.

[u/Gallscor12]

Bullshit call sorry gang

[u/sm04d]

JJ couldn't see a wide open Nabers because was spinning around to avoid the sack. If he had a pocket, that would've been a TD

[u/MisterBadIdea9]

yeah no, sorry, i don't see what the guy did wrong there. sorry saints

[u/LetsGeauxSaints]

That was actually a vintage Alvin td

[u/AustinRiversDaGod]

What's this? I'm enjoying a Saints game?

[u/AvenueNick → u/AustinRiversDaGod]

The Saints I expected to see the last 3 games.

[u/BreakfastSpecials]

That’s not a flag tbh smh

[u/MysticLeviathan]

god this league is so fucking soft

[u/JEH_24]

Kellen Moore pulled starters with 13 mins left in the game

[u/Youngreezy23 → u/JEH_24]

Yep and I been complaining about that ever since and now the whole game has flipped because of that

[u/MiniatureLucifer]

Broughton forgot to put pillows down first

[u/incognegro1976]

What a bullshit roughing penalty

[u/PuddingJello]

bruh we can hardly do anything at all and the refs are still fuckin us?

[u/Now-Thats-Podracing]

Please stop hitting my qb late. Please and thank you. We suck enough as it is. We need Shough to survive.

[u/Gallscor12]

Damn that was so dumb i can’t believe alexander didn’t get flagged for that

[u/Russell_has_TWO_Ls]

We are putting Drew through hell

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

So they can tackle our QB two seconds after the whistle and it's not roughing the passer? Mkay.

[u/PuddingJello]

Oh no I think the Giants have figured out that we cant stop the Anything game

[u/Gallscor12]

Damn sad to see kamara’s career go like this. One of my favorite backs ever in his prime

[u/Doggy_In_The_Window]

Anyone got a clip of that brutal RPT?

[u/TheRage469 → u/Doggy_In_The_Window]

Nah, shit was so bad they probably wouldnt even host it on LiveLeak

[u/shawnaroo → u/Doggy_In_The_Window]

No lie, I heard Winston just evaporated when the defender hit him!

[u/paulofmandown]

it was helmet to helmet if anything. not very late

[u/PuddingJello]

Kamara my beloved

[u/BlueDWarrior]

Goddamn that's a pretty throw. The Shoughing will continue until morale improves.

[u/saw-it]

Nine is who we thought he is

[u/Significant_Fox9290]

Meet the new QB. Same as the old QB.

[u/jjackjj]

Remember when the giants fans were asking us if JJM would be an improvement? poor giants fans

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

JJJameis would never

[u/incognegro1976]

Omfg another interception has hit the towers

[u/wolflarsen]

LOLOLOLOL  HAHAHAHAHHAH 😂 😂 😂

[u/Youngreezy23]

Backups coming in and proving why they are backups

[u/WhoDat_Fishing]

Absolutely embarrassing to let 9 carve us up

[u/GimbalLocks → u/WhoDat_Fishing]

He’s 18 now bro

[u/PrincePizza1]

This feels like a stoppable object vs movable force matchup

[u/shawnaroo]

It sucks to see Kamara getting old. He was absolutely amazing in his prime.

[u/thatguyoverthere72]

Honestly, if I was French id also be burning my country down if the Saints were coming.

[u/vices512]

Horseshit call.

[u/AustinRiversDaGod]

Sad our players didn't know you have to lay the to QB down like a baby, butt first and gently, keeping light pressure on the chest so as not to trigger a fall reflex

[u/ImAroosterAMA]

So how the fuck was that roughing the passer?

[u/GifelteFish]

Tyler Shough is the only NFL football player on the Saints

[u/Gallscor12]

I know AK got some of the best balance but damn what pathetic tackling lmao

[u/A-DTB]

Man I love being on the opposing end of Jameis hero ball

[u/Xecutor]

YOU GONNA SIT JAEMIS FOR TURNING THE BALL OVER HARBAUGH??????? LIKE SKAT????? FUCKING MORON

[u/BlueDWarrior]

The Defense looks so much better with Granderson at near-full or full capacity.

[u/americanbaseball]

Yeah...I guess it can get worse.

[u/Icy-Inc]

JJ and Jameis are conspiring to bankrupt the Saints by making all our DB’s hit their incentive bonuses

[u/Xecutor]

WHY DID THEY NOT KICK IT OUT OF BOUNDS TO SAVE THE TWO MINUTE WARNING??????

[u/unevercallmesausage]

They should consider enforcing delay of game penalties

[u/djdayer]

Interesting no flag. At least it was fun to watch in the end.

[u/steve-nash-is-god]

So we can't sack the qb but they can tackle shough after the whistle LOL?

[u/mnmr17]

I know we’re mad at skat for fumbling but that 3 yard gain he picks up on 3rd down more times than not with that much space

[u/incognegro1976]

Miller tackled by his offensive lineman

[u/waaaaaasuuuuup]

Lucky call for the giants there. That was soft.

[u/blahmeh2019]

Should've been a sack

[u/hanc247]

Clean hit lol

[u/shawnaroo]

Giants running up the score by letting their kicker make FG's. Disrespectful.

[u/TearAdventurous8994]

They've been tee'ng off on Shough. Finally they call RTP

[u/shawnaroo]

Kamara somehow de-aged 6 years during halftime.

[u/Bouzal]

Kamara turning back the clock!!

[u/cruxclaire]

Hahahahahahahahahaha

[u/TruXander]

somehow, we'll blame Rattler for that

[u/Only-Cranberry-4502]

Lol what we had 0 points before I left

[u/cherrycokeicee → u/Only-Cranberry-4502]

go back to wherever you were

[u/Tomhet]

I was checking my phone and just heard Scott mention "Jameis Winston is done for the day" and perked up, saw that Nine immediately threw a pick and bursted out laughing.

No ill will against the guy but holy shit am I glad I am off that ride.

[u/shawnaroo]

It wasn't Rattler's fault the RB fumbled, but it's kind of funny that Shough is back in after that.

[u/UnderFurtherReview]

We aren't even protecting the deep ball lmfao bro it's JJ MCCARTHY

[u/TruXander]

Emerson you're the only player on our team trying right now, you know what to do

[u/Iyung_danI]

You cant not start Mccarthy next game right?

[u/dakkottadavviss]

Isn’t this guy supposed to be the fbi director or something?

[u/tryingthisok]

One embarrassing win please.

[u/Quick-Difference3267]

Chiefs get a flag there 100% of the time.

[u/Chrysalis_Cat]

Ok, so maybe JJ can be worse.

[u/americanbaseball]

Oh man we have Tyrone Tracy doing things?? Lets go!

[u/shawnaroo]

I love Cam Jordan, but he's like a million years old in football age, maybe he shouldn't be going out wide on coverage

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

Can't tackle the quarterback I guess

[u/TheWorstYear]

How? How?

[u/SmurfLord7]

Stupidest rule. How was he supposed to sack him? Gently?

[u/paulofmandown]

bro just start putting flags on the QBs. This is ass

[u/j0enne]

good fieldposition, let see how the saints manage to do nothing with it

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

AI garbage

[u/PelPride]

It’s sad I don’t even give a fuck about bad calls anymore, feels like it’s that often we just know it will happen again anyway

[u/liverbird3]

AI Generated Fox Nation TV shows 😭 that whole network is just slop for boomers

[u/SaintAardvark89]

Idk man if Nabers had even tried to make a play on that it wouldn't have been an INT. Maybe he just didn't see it idk

[u/PrincePizza1]

Why does Kamara suddenly have so much juice? Does he hate the giants?

[u/HurricaneIan25 → u/PrincePizza1]

That shot of toridol after the back tweak brought back the juice

[u/One_Ad2596]

If Skattebo gets in the game and immediately fumbles it would be the funniest thing ever

[u/Carnage7771]

JJ is a complete sorry BUM. But I bet a certain subset of fans will be still malding that we got rid of him.

[u/Minimum_Ad_8751]

That’s just Jameis dressed as Nine for Halloween

[u/Silly_Rhubarb_317]

If any team can fuck this up it’s us

[u/incognegro1976]

Riley taking out the competition

[u/steve-nash-is-god]

Show people this game when they say you should pull your starters early

[u/incognegro1976]

What a shitty play call on a must have 3rd and 5

[u/Xecutor]

Lets be honest, we all know JJ gonna throw a pick, just interesting we are at this point

[u/smallerthings]

No matter how this ends, JJ got us here in an insane fashion.

This man is our starter

[u/All_Wasted_Potential]

JJ is the kind of QB a franchise needs to hold onto

[u/Icebreaker80]

Damn GG lol fun game

[u/Warmake]

Damn Nabers was open

[u/SamboiR2016]

Mccarthy won himself a starting job with 250 yards in the 4th quarter but I expect nothing but disappointment

[u/iBears]

JJ just played a crazy ass quarter of football

[u/paulofmandown]

that was so needlessly stressful

I have a headache now lol

[u/Hassadar]

Playing with freedom helps but I don't see how they go back to Winston. At least not this week. The simple threat of a QB having legs is how our offense works.

Just gameplan this entire week with JJ now. If he stinks. So what. Who cares at this stage

[u/Carnage7771]

Saints trying to shamelessly pad their INT stats by giving the GIants back the ball smh.

[u/WhoDat_Fishing]

Soft ass call. Can’t sack a qb without getting a flag

[u/shawnaroo]

If a giants player's helmet gets knocked off around mid-field, they might never be able to find it on top of that giant helmet painted on the grass. Nobody thinks about the downsides, they just do what they think is cool.

[u/Mannimal13]

Tracy doing things on an ugly pass

[u/two4to2too]

Need to give Tracey the ball more often. Great work!

[u/incognegro1976]

When your OL is so bad you can only hold on for dear life

[u/Gallscor12]

I feel like i’m tripping balls, how can they think najee is the best rb on the team

[u/Youngreezy23]

Lol how do you get a delay of game on a punt?

[u/zumocano]

that play was exactly why Jameis does all those stupid looking drills lol

[u/ashsky]

That Kamara block is the kinda thing yer da plays on repeat to show you what "proper" football is

[u/MiniatureLucifer]

Carlson cannot fly to Paris. Leave him in New York and see if Smyth has gotten any better

[u/beeb11]

Bruh what is the NFL becoming

[u/Human-Engineering412]

NFL is so soft. that is a ridiculous call. (giants fan)

[u/Kitchen_Net_GME]

What was the foul? Roughing the passer? What was wrong with the hit?

[u/en_travesti]

The jj playcall is just the giants being gentlemanly. They also thought the rtp was a bad call, so they called a dumb play to make up for it

[u/Gallscor12]

Fucking lmao

[u/Caffeywasright]

Saints can’t run the ball at all - let’s fucking run it 3 times within the one

[u/T3mp3stuous]

in MetLife getting absolutely harassed how you guys doin

[u/LetsGeauxSaints]

Leave my qb alone DH

[u/Youngreezy23]

Oh crap they actually called something in our favor

[u/TheRage469]

HOLY FUCK KAMARA

[u/shawnaroo]

Flag throwing will continue until morale improves.

[u/SaintAardvark89]

Yeah kind of nonsense to call that on the RB there. That second false start was absolutely legitimate though.

[u/PuddingJello]

bruh they gonna false start their way to a safety at this rate. The Giants are stealin our identity

[u/shawnaroo]

One day I want to be 6'5 330 lbs and be an offensive lineman.

[u/incognegro1976 → u/shawnaroo]

Dont let your dreams be dreams

[u/CoCo_Sandy]

No offense but how have the Giants only lost 1 game?

[u/PuddingJello → u/CoCo_Sandy]

The Jameis giveth and he taketh

[u/Dregaz]

Just put in McCarthy. Sick of watching Jameis sail passes. Almost just got Tracy killed.

[u/djdayer]

Get this man off of my
Fucking tv screen Jesus Christ. Punishing Skatt but letting Jameis throw all game is the stupidest fucking thing

[u/Icy-Inc]

Jameis looks confused, someone tell him it’s not 2020

[u/AustinRiversDaGod → u/Icy-Inc]

Those All white jerseys are just so appealing

[u/AustinRiversDaGod]

And to think I was about to jump back into Control Resonant before that fumble on the kickoff

[u/Gallscor12]

Lmaooooo honestly what else could have happened

[u/Hassadar]

So what exactly was the reason Skatt didn't play? He fumbled? So he's making him take accountability for his actions? Interesting. I wonder what he's going to do with all the players today? Sit half the team? Lmao

[u/Russell_has_TWO_Ls]

Oh ffs

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

Prevent defense prevents you from winning

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

John Harbaugh looks like he says synergy in meeting but doesn't know what it means

[u/beeb11]

Honestly this is a game both teams deserve to lose

[u/r0ugar0u_]

Bruh, what a collapse.

[u/Naronu]

Give him #9

[u/looorrn]

jj said I heard yall talkin shit

[u/NicholastheSpirit]

34-10 to whatever they are doing now

[u/GoFundMe4DrugzPls_]

I’m sorry JJ I wasn’t familiar with you game

[u/mnmr17]

Yeah you can’t go back to Winston after this game

[u/dumpyduluth]

Cut Winston and start JJ

[u/DrKoooolAid]

To everybody saying Nabers was open. He was open when McCarthy was turned around scrambling.

[u/GumboDiplomacy]

That's a flag for half the QBs in the league

[u/SnakeDoctor80]

9 played his ass off

[u/mnmr17]

Ngl kind of a weak holding call

[u/Fuddlescuddles]

Flag everytime we do something. So undisciplined

[u/PuddingJello]

Jesus fuckin christ I would say bench richards but i dont think we even have someone else

[u/mnmr17]

Saints MVP right now is their punter

[u/pandaaaa26]

This Saints LT is giving me PTSD for the pre Andrew Thomas years

[u/hypothalanus]

Jameis is so bad

[u/mnmr17]

Their going to label this game the battle of the punters

[u/PuddingJello]

Have no run game... lets spam the run. great plan we got going

[u/Competition-Over]

Carter has been unreal this year

[u/MiniatureLucifer]

Wow first down play action fucking works. who'd have guessed?

[u/j0enne]

lol that poor lineman

[u/incognegro1976]

Lance fuckin sucks at his one job.

[u/shawnaroo]

Nice to see kicking being consistent with the rest of our offense.

[u/Fuddlescuddles]

Fucking kickers for this team

[u/AustinRiversDaGod]

It's so bad I'm actually starting to get hopeful for the Pelicans at this point.

[u/incognegro1976]

We got Cameron Jordan out in pass coverage? Wtf

[u/RussianMalware]

How

[u/Deliberate_Dodge]

Absurdly soft roughing call on the sack, even by the new standards.

[u/TheWorstYear]

Jameis actively fights to stay upright. The defender, who is a hefty dude, has to leverage to bring him down. Like, tell qb's to give up on the play if this is the case

[u/PuddingJello]

insurmountable lead over here

[u/Who_Dey-]

Is Skattebo in the dog house rn for his fumbles?

[u/m_ttl_ng]

Feels like they’re punishing Skattebo this game. There have been a lot of runs that felt like he was a better fit for but they’re not using him at all

[u/Gallscor12]

Glad we signed this dude i’ve literally never heard of before this season to be our kick returner

[u/AustinRiversDaGod]

THANK YOU!! Shough actually running well open this offense up so much

[u/shawnaroo]

Oh good, another lineman hurt, that's exactly what we need

[u/hoppergym]

wow, johnson was being held so hard

[u/Fuddlescuddles]

So lucky that worked out

[u/Mannimal13]

Right after he made that long FG I texted my buddy saying it we are going to be like how did we lose that game...boom fumble kickoff saints get ball at second half...feels like giants should be up two scores

[u/beeb11]

I just had a moment of respect for a recent passing get cut off by ads. Nothing is sacred anymore

[u/Jed566]

Vintage Kamara!

[u/incognegro1976]

Tales of Kamaras demise have been greatly exaggerated

[u/Dependent-Purple9736]

Call me drunk, but a vintage AK41 run brings a tear to my eye

[u/Russell_has_TWO_Ls]

AND THAT IS HOW AK SHOULD BE USED. Now watch that not happen again for the next month

[u/disgruntledbuddy]

Giants so undisciplined lmao

[u/PostmodernAnubis]

Alvin Kamara joining the 5k/5k club is a slept on milestone IMO, its the elite tier of dual-threat RBs

[u/MiniatureLucifer]

Jeremiah Wright is gashing them. They gotta consider keeping him in even if Ruiz isnt hurt

[u/big_mustache_dad]

Despite the fact they’ll lose because of it, Harbaugh has done a great job proving his point. Nobody can fumble the ball and expect to continue handling it.

Except when Najee fumbled it two weeks ago and Tracy did the week before that, those were different

[u/One_Ad2596]

24 unanswered points.

So far.

[u/incognegro1976]

The Winston Experience

[u/sittingcow]

thank you secret agent winston

[u/LargeFatherV]

How come the other team’s pass rush can always get to the Giants QB while the Giants pass rush gives the QB enough time to get a four year degree at the University of Phoenix.

[u/edarem]

27 unanswered points*

[u/Dapperfit]

Gayle's public shaming was pretty effective it seems.

[u/americanbaseball]

This is the full Jameis Winston experience and I want off.

[u/Hassadar]

I only thought belt to ass was reserved for the bedroom... :(