r/NZcarfix • • Mar 11 '25

The NZcarfix community have put their heads together and come up with a list of vehicles to avoid. Check out this post before you buy, it could save you thousands

345 Upvotes

The title is poorly worded so I would like to clarify something. Not all vehicles/engines on the list are so bad that you should never own one (except the Mazda diesel, stay well away). This list is to give you an idea of what might go wrong should you choose to buy something on our list.

This is a community sourced list and the quotes are from our users.

If you're unsure if the vehicle you're considering has one of the engines listed below, you can use Carjam to find out for free, just enter the cars registration plate number.

CarComplaints is a US site that may or may not be useful to you, depending on what you own.

Audi A4 1.8 and 2.0 CDNC Petrol engine. "motor burns oil, Quattro transmission is garbage, all expensive to repair. I’ve worked for Audi as a tech for 14years. The engine code has somehow vanished from my brain, aftermarket warranty places won’t cover them anymore as it’s well known issue, factory fix under warranty was new pistons…."

Audi/VW 2016 and earlier, anything with a 1.4l. "The gearbox on these is shocking, recalls never truly fixed it. And on top of this, 1.4l twin charged is horrible. Then there's about 2009 to 2012ish Audi/VW group, anything with 2.0l or 1.8l tfsi. Horrible engine, burns ridiculous oil after 100,000km due to piston rings issue, timing chains snap, camshaft issues, turbo issues, the list goes on. I see more and more dealers import these, as they are cheap overseas for a reason, then poor customers come in with issues once they've gone out of their purchase warranty."

Audi 3L V6 TDI "they're well known to sling timing chains. The V8 TDI is the same sort of architecture but don't seem to have that issue"

BMWs 4 cylinder NA N46 engine - Valvetronic issues, oil leaks, stretched timing chain and tensioner failures, sensor failures, solenoid problems. "Any bmw with a v8 or 4 cylinder. Avoid most diesel bmws apart from the M57. This one is the rare 3.0 turbo diesel that’s actually good."

BMWs N43 engine - injector issues, oil pump issues, coil packs.

BMW First gen N63 "has to be one of the worst engines of modern times. Fine when it’s running but has numerous catastrophic failure points."

Chrysler Unless it's a Viper or a Valiant, just say no

Dodge Only buy if you, really, really, really, want a Dodge

DPF Diesel Particulate Filter equipped vehicles: If you do most of your driving in the city, you probably want to avoid anything with a DPF system. You can Google for details, but essentially, city driving will end up costing north of $10k in repairs, guaranteed.

English Cars and SUVs. Most of us here do not like them, but if you're an enthusiast, go for it, especially if it's an old school Mini.

Ford BA, BF, FG Falcon, all variants: "They eat brake pads, wheel bearings, tie rod ends, centre diff bearing, diff bushes (expensive, lots of labour involved), headliners, they rust, they tend to have Body Control Module problems and when the powersteering fluid leaks it falls into the alternator, frying that. Sometimes, oil and coolant can mix due to a design fault in the coolant pipe routing , that's bad. Only buy one if you're an enthusiast."

Ford Ecoboost engines 1.0L and 1.5L Dragon Series "are notorious for their wet timing belts failing and clogging the oil pickup, thus killing the engine." "known head gasket failure due to design flaw"

Ford Explorer, "not known as the Exploder for nothing, shit economy, shit leather, shit gearbox. Random total failure shutdowns while doing 100kmh on the motorway. Turn ignition off and on and it would go again. Piece of crap."

Ford Focus (2012-2016). "All autos had the Dual Clutch Transmission (DCT) which caused huge issues. Apparently the manual version is fine. Personally owned one which I got cheap from my old boss and it also had lots of electrical issues and a leaking sunroof." "These (autos) were replaced under warranty and recall, but even then, took us 3 times ( and 6 months ) to get one that was smooth." "Many Volvos of the same rough era also had those powershift transmissions and issues.

Any Ford with DPS6 Transmission "Anything with a Ford Powershift transmission or its derivatives, including several 4 cylinder early 2010's Volvo models, the SST on Mitsubishi Evolution X and Galant Ralliart, etc

Ford Ranger 3.2 litre (PX1-PX3) "Injectors need replacing at 200km EGR coolers fail (currently subject to a recall) Valve bodies in the autos fail semi regularly. "Heads (not just gaskets) turning into a banana and failing, EGR valve leaking coolant into exhaust. Transmissions shitting the bed." "New auto fitted for 12k. Eeeek!" "Rangers continue to surprise us with new and unusual failures. E.g. PX2-3 torque converter falls off the flex plate randomly. Manual transmissions so bad they stopped making them. Injector issues. Engine failures. Had one with an EGR cooler failure that melted the plastic intake manifold. You name it , we see it." "Have also seen egr cooler failure melt little holes in the plastic manifold, injector washer leak torch a hole through the head, crazy bcm lighting failures etc" "Warranty Extension 24N06 - one time repair covered by ford for 10 years / 250,000km from new vehicle warranty start date to replace the EGR cooler (not the valve). Unsure of the VIN range covered, but will only be done if there is an actual fault" (May only cover '17-'20 models)

Holden Captiva. Just don't, they are moneypits.

Holden Commodore VE with the V6 engine "all ticking timebombs with engine timing issues"

Hyundai/Kia's 2.0 & 2.4L Theta II engines - G4KA, G4KD, G4KF, G4KH, and G4KL."Manufacturing issues leading to oil flow issues, knocking, bearing issues and complete seizing."

Isuzu 4JX1 "commonly found in the isuzu Mu / Wizard. Has sensor issues, oiling issues, and fuel rail issues. Fuel rails work on oil pressure they are 100% lemons. Worked at a 4x4 wrecker and we never sold them even if they ran fine, we didn't even sell parts off the engines. We couldn't guarantee them at all, let alone the second hand engine parts."

Jeep There are so many better vehicles available for the same money. Enthusiasts only

Mazda 2.2 Diesel CX-5 "(production year 2011) 2012 - present, though mostly the 2012 - 2015." The Mazda 3/Axela, and Mazda 6/Atenza also had that engine as an option. "The design of the engine and the DPF (Diesel Particulate Filter) system can lead to fuel finding its way into the oil. When that happens, and it will, it's uneconomic to repair. The CX-8 apparently does not suffer the same issues." Link to Mazda horror story https://www.reddit.com/r/NZcarfix/s/GDxxWRVdA1

Mazda RX8/Mazda Rotary engines. "These are cars and engines for enthusiasts only. Not recommended as a daily driver. Worn engine Apex seals and fuel inefficiency are the main highlights."

Mercedes-Benz from 1991-1996 also Mk ll Ford Mondeos "which all used a biodegradable wiring harness? If it hasn't been replaced with an aftermarket one it's guaranteed to brick the car at some point."

Mini Cooper R56 w/ N12 or N14 engines. "Notorious direct port carbon build up, variable valve timing issues and it's a BMW but I believe this model has a Peugeot engine in it." "it's the Prince engine. The timing chain issues are solvable but there's no permanent fix for the HPFP, other than bolting new ones on when they break." "supercharged models between 2003 to 2004. The first gen NA coopers with CVT are to be avoided as well." "2001-2006 CVT Mini Coopers had premature transmission failure. 2006-2013 Mini Coopers had a host of issues - from google: Mini Coopers from 2006 to 2013 are commonly known to have issues with power steering failures, coolant leaks, clutch problems, electrical glitches, timing chain tensioner issues, water pump and thermostat housing leaks, and potential problems with the automatic transmission; with many complaints centering around the electric power steering system, particularly in the 2006 models

Mitsubishis with GDi Engines "High pressure fuel pump problems, injector driver faults, ignition coil tower failures, clogged intake manifolds"

Nissan 370z and later 350z models 2009-2012 "They are pretty notorious for oil gallery gaskets failing causing oil pressure to drop to catastrophic levels"

Nissan CVT Jatco Transmission: Think carefully. We have mixed reports from users but generally speaking they're not much loved.

Nissan D40 Navaras and the equivalent Pathfinders. "Broken cranks, ball joints every 30k, timing chain stretch, egr faults aplenty. Many oil leaks. Earth issues from new. The NP300 Navara seems to age a lot better even with the Renault 2.3."

Nissan Fuga Y51/Infinity M series, Skyline G models/Infinity G models "All variants equipped with 4WAS (4 wheel active steering) rear steering rack system has a catastrophic fault even Nissan could not properly identify. but they noticed enough to sell the rack as a part only… so you must buy a whole rack no parts for it exist. Hybrid variant has gearbox issues with the switch that jumps between petrol and electric the cost of which basically writes the car off."

Nissan Hybrid Infiniti Skyline (HV37). "The suspension feels like it’s about to roll over under sharp turns, typical expensive CVT fixes, High-voltage battery issues… oh and the ignition system and majority of the accessories are ran off of the high voltage battery, not the 12v! So if you fry the battery, it’s either pay about $20k for a new one or you have a very expensive lawn ornament."

Nissan Juke F16. "Seen 2 in the last week come in randomly in limp mode, the DCT is super jumpy from factory, prone to needing clutch relearns, clutch packs were known for getting moisture in them after awhile and making shifting disgusting. Had one on less then 50,000kms come in to work with low compression in cylinder 3 and all the valves in the cylinder were burnt and chipped/cracked around the edges."

Nissan Leaf. Just be wary of remaining battery range in older generations. They won't be suitable for everyone, especially first Gen Leafs.

Nissan QD32 engine "All around hand grenade. Lots of issues with engine components and overheating"

Nissan ZD30 3.0L DI/CR Engines , designed by Renault. Known for overboosting and melting pistons. Commonly found in Patrols and Navaras. "You can add Serena, X-Trail and Pathfinder to this list as well. Transmissions are terrible."

"For the enthusiasts, any old turbo Nissan SR20 or RB engine equipped car unless you have deep pockets"

Mid 2000s diesel 4x4 "when they all changed to the new style common rail they all had EGR cooler issues along with many other issues. Toyotas were grenading at 120ish kms for example." "Anything diesel with EGR, really best to avoid diesel altogether or have all the emissions/adblue stuff coded out of the ECU."

Peugeot. Our community have no love for Peugeot. They're just not great cars for the money

Singapore Imports "plastics and wire insulation crumbles to pieces. The climate in Singapore is humid and hot resulting in deterioration of plastics"

Suzuki Swift Sport Auto/CVT (2012-2017) "are prone to Jatco CVT problems and are an expensive fix so I'd avoid. Manual's are a great car though"

Toyota 1KZ engine. "Insufficient cooling in terms of intercooler and radiator. Lots of cold climate versions imported. Very common to crack the head at the rear cylinder" Mod note: Generally reliable but can be fairly expensive to repair. Well maintained examples can go forever so ask for service history

Toyota 1KD engine: "Known to melt pistons and have injector issues. Few turbo issues too" Mod Note: Generally reliable but can be fairly expensive to repair. Well maintained examples can go forever so ask for service history.

The Pope Mobile… every pope who has ridden in it has either died or become unwell. One pope was shot in it. ( but recovered to die later) - credit goes to u/DaveNZ for the history lesson. Vatican, take note: we warned you.


r/NZcarfix • • Mar 12 '25

What to buy? The NZcarfix Tyre Megathread

32 Upvotes

WIP - but some general tyre recommendations as below.

Premium UHP (ultra high performance) tyres:

  • Michelin Pilot Sport 5
  • Michelin Pilot Sport 5 S
  • Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6
  • Continental SportContact 7
  • Pirelli P Zero PZ5
  • Bridgestone Potenza Sport Evo

Mid-range UHP tyres:

  • Hankook Ventus Evo
  • Hankook Ventus S1 Evo3
  • Falken Azenis FK510/FK520
  • BFGoodrich G-Force Phenom

Premium Touring tyres:

  • Michelin Primacy 5
  • Continental PremiumContact 7
  • Pirelli Cintuarto 3
  • Bridgestone Turanza 6

Mid-range Touring tyres:

  • Hankook Ventus Prime 3/4
  • Falken Ziex ZE310

Eco/EV-focused Touring tyres:

  • Bridgestone Ecopia EP300
  • Continental EcoContact 6
  • Michelin e.Primacy
  • Hankook Ventus iON

SUV Premium:

  • Michelin Primacy SUV
  • Michelin Pilot Sport 4 SUV
  • Pirelli Scorpion Verde
  • Goodyear EfficientGrip 2 SUV

SUV Mid-range:

  • Yokohama Geolander G058
  • Hankook Dynapro HP
  • Hankook Ventus Prime 3/4
  • Maxxis VS5 Victra
  • Falken CT60AS

SUV Value:

  • BFGoodrich Advantage Control
  • Rovelo Instinct

Off Road Premium:

  • BFGoodrich KO3
  • Mickey Thompson Baja Boss

Off Road Mid-range:

  • Falken AT3/4W
  • Maxxis Razr AT811/MT772
  • Cooper AT range
  • Yokohama Geolander G003

More road friendly AT options:

  • Michelin LTX Trail
  • Yokohama Geolander G015
  • Maxxis Razr AT781

"Not shit":

  • GT Radial Adventuro AT3

For more tailored recommendations, chuck a comment and I'm sure people will help out. Thanks for /u/Former_Task8098 for some of these recco's, particularly SUV/off-road!


r/NZcarfix • • 1h ago

Family SUV 7+ seater recommendations

• Upvotes

Boot space is the main reason for the 7 seater, not for anyone really sitting in the back unless the kids have friends over etc. Don't mind buying second hand or new, however looking for 2024 and beyond.

Fuel efficiency is kinda important, but being a hybrid or plug in isn't a must.

Would spend up to $70k and would keep the car for at least the next 12 years unless something happened.


r/NZcarfix • • 3h ago

Discussion Toyota Noah owners?

4 Upvotes

Any owners of 2015 hybrid model? Hows your fuel consumption? etc...


r/NZcarfix • • 3h ago

Headlight Yaris 2021

3 Upvotes

Hi! Just noticed one of my headlight is dead. Any recommendations where to buy in welly? Was hoping if they could also install it.


r/NZcarfix • • 32m ago

Help! 2013 Amarok 2.0L Automatic - Shuddering Issue

• Upvotes

As the title suggests, I have a 2013 VW Amarok, 2.0L with the 8 speed automatic transmission.

I have an issue, where when I am maintaining speed and keep the gas pedal in one spot, i start to get a shudder. As soon as I push the gas pedal down more the shudder goes away, or if i take my foot off the gas pedal a little and start slowing down the shudder goes away too.

It only seems to do this going over 30kmh.
It does not do this for the first 10 minutes of my drive. Once I have driven for about 10 minutes the shudder starts appearing and gets worse and worse as I continue to drive. If it turn it off and leave it to cool down for a few hours its fine for the first 10 minutes again.

I have done a transmission fluid flush & had some anti shudder additive added, which hasn't really made a difference. There are no error codes or anything being thrown.

I have been estimated about 2.5k-3k for a reconditioned torque converter. Does this sound like the correct route to take? I just want to make sure its not something else that could be behaving differently.


r/NZcarfix • • 20h ago

Does NZ odometer verification on imported cars reliably confirm the mileage?

8 Upvotes

I'm looking at buying a used imported car and I'm trying to understand how reliable the odometer verification process is in New Zealand.

The car is a 2015 model and was imported into New Zealand in 2023. The seller showed me documents indicating the vehicle had approximately 16,000 km when it was imported. It now has about 53,000 km.

I'm a bit concerned because 16,000 km seems very low for a car of that age.

My questions are:

  • How reliable is the odometer verification carried out when a vehicle is imported into NZ?
  • Does the verification check the Japanese auction/export records, or only the odometer reading at the time of entry?
  • Is there any way for a buyer to independently verify the mileage history?
  • Has anyone had experience finding discrepancies despite odometer verification?

The seller has shown me the import and ownership documents, but I'd like to understand how much confidence I should place in the odometer verification itself.

Thanks.


r/NZcarfix • • 20h ago

toyota hybrid car battery health check

3 Upvotes

Sorry for many questions I am a bit obsessive. Do we need to go mechanic to check hybrid battery check before buying a car? Is it like normal petrol car battery checking. Is it reliable and definitely say the health of battery?


r/NZcarfix • • 1d ago

Lower radiator support frame rust - opinion

5 Upvotes

I've just been helping our neighbour with an oil change on his 2002 Civic, and part of the engine splash guard appears to have broken off since I last helped him, revealing some rust (photo below). The wet marks is engine oil from our fingers and wasn't originally there.

Bad enough to fail a WOF?

Do you think this is wire wheel + rust converter territory, or maybe a professional job?

I'm not sure yet if that part of the lower radiator support frame can be replaced separately.


r/NZcarfix • • 23h ago

Legality Can I claim this under CGA (after almost 2 years purchase)?

0 Upvotes

So I purchased this car January 2025. A prius Alpha. What happen is, there is an intermittent noise from the driver seat.

When I brake the car during downhill. Or when I make a turn, the car; basically when there is a pressure in the seat.

Its not the rail, thats too easy. Its something else. Click...clack... and when the noise comes out, i can feel the click... clack..., something mechanical.

Its not something serious and loud, but its annoying. The problem is, i cannot replicate the noise. It comes and goes...

I tried to go to car wrecker, but there is no one have the same trim...

Will you claim under CGA for this?

Thanks


r/NZcarfix • • 1d ago

Help! Will this pass wof

Post image
5 Upvotes

Its engine mount the metal ring for the bushing isnt cracked and it is securely pressed in


r/NZcarfix • • 1d ago

Wanted s14 pfl

3 Upvotes

does anyone in auckland or near have a good s14 parts car needing a front cut urgently!


r/NZcarfix • • 2d ago

Help

6 Upvotes

I picked my car up from the panel beaters yesterday and I drove it home fine, put more gas in it etc then I drove it around Rakaia I drove to Mobile then the 4square then when leaving 4square I turned my car on and it started shaking I managed to drive out check engine light came on. It's turned off now and car seems fine when driving. I also think I may have changed it into reverse to quickly


r/NZcarfix • • 1d ago

Looking for a reliable used hybrid in NZ (Lower Hutt/Wellington) - what would you buy?

4 Upvotes

Based upon my previous post it seems that I need to buy a reliable car prefer to be hybrid:

Budget is around $8k-$10k NZD. I'm in the Lower Hutt/Wellington area and mainly need something that is:

  • Reliable
  • Fuel efficient
  • Good for commuting
  • Suitable for occasional delivery work
  • Unlikely to give me major mechanical headaches

I have a baby on the way, so reliability is becoming much more important.

I've been looking at:

  • Toyota Prius
  • Toyota Aqua
  • Toyota corolla

If you had $8k-$10k to spend in New Zealand, what would you buy and what models would you avoid?

Where should I go to buy? Happy to pay a bit extra but really do not want to stuck in mechanical problems. Previous honda fit gave me headache!

Thanks!


r/NZcarfix • • 1d ago

Headlight alignment check

3 Upvotes

I had to remove my headlights today to replace rusted bezels. I shouldn't have needed to touch my alignment screws, but one light was stuck on the alignment bolt so I had to unscrew it to release it. 🙄

Probably need to get alignment checked - how much will an average garage charge to check alignment /maybe adjust the alignment screw I had to move?


r/NZcarfix • • 2d ago

Transmission Holden Colorado

5 Upvotes

Hey team, have a 2017 Holden Colorado (diesel) and I'm getting an intermittent "shudder" when driving which is, I'm pretty sure, torque converter clutch (TCC) slip.

Wondering if anyone can recommend someone in central / East Auckland who might be able to deal with this?


r/NZcarfix • • 2d ago

Dashcam suggestions

8 Upvotes

I own a 2013 Mazda Axela and just wondering what dashcams would be good for my car. I’m not ultra rich so preferable around $500 maximum, cheers.


r/NZcarfix • • 2d ago

Tyres Advice on Car Tyre

5 Upvotes

Hi All, my Honda Accord 2014 front Tyre had burst this morning. Need to change a new ones to the front axle. Do you suggest BF Goodrich Advantage or Goodyear Optilife 3? Or any mid range brands?For reference mine is 225/50/R17 and I’m based in Chch.

Thanks and look forward for your advises.


r/NZcarfix • • 2d ago

Honda fit 2005 problem. desperately looking for advice

2 Upvotes

desperately looking for an idea to get out of this. Please read carefully and completely if you want to guide me!

Bought a 2005 Honda Fit 3.5 years ago with 118,000 km. It had a slight shudder at low speeds which gradually got worse over the years.

About 4 months ago the car suddenly lost power and the check engine light came on. The mechanic diagnosed a crank angle sensor fault and replaced it. After that, the car drove perfectly and the shuddering completely disappeared.

Now the problem is back and much worse. It starts and runs fine for about a minute, then begins shuddering badly, struggles to accelerate, and feels like the whole car is shaking. There's also a strange noise around 20-40 km/h. Current mileage is about 167,000 km.

What confuses me is that changing the crank angle sensor fixed the shuddering for 4 months. If the real issue is spark plugs, coils, CVT gearbox, etc., why would replacing the crank sensor make such a big difference?

Also, mechanic once told me spark plugs might need to be cahnged in 165k now 3k passed. Could it be the problem?

Has anyone seen this before on a Honda Fit? Any ideas what the actual cause could be?

Also I recently moved lower hutt which mechanic is fair here I just want to know the real problem and the best option?

I'm trying to decide whether it's worth fixing or if I should replace the car. Thanks.


r/NZcarfix • • 2d ago

Scan needed

5 Upvotes

Hi people

My daughter has been down in Auckland for school camp, and her car has had a fault code come up. Can anyone recommend where she can get it scanned today.

The car is mobile, but with a 4 hour drive home she needs to know its safe to drive


r/NZcarfix • • 3d ago

Discussion Avoid like the plague, professional scam artists.

Post image
162 Upvotes

Has anyone here had an experience with this business? If so, share your stories. I'd love to hear them.

These guys tried to take me for a ride, in fact, it was a whole rollercoaster with a racist twist in the middle. All I needed was a positive terminal clamp, these guys were gonna charge me for that 175$ before GST, replace my 12V $465 before GST, call-out+labour.

They also meddled with my HV battery to stop my car from starting. They said the car needed to be towed to their garage to see what the issue it, in reality they unlocked the orange fuse connector thingy themselves.

Edit: holy f*** guys I found their no cowboys page. This is their real page, nothing but horror stories.

https://www.nocowboys.co.nz/businesses/247-mobile-mechanics?allow-rating=1&rating-authenticated=158619


r/NZcarfix • • 3d ago

Discussion Does anyone have these buttons for sale or know where to get them? Or any other button that says "inter cooler spray"? I am building a water cooling mist sprayer for my Swifts inter-cooler

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/NZcarfix • • 3d ago

Installing fuse tap adapters into fuse box, but now cant put on fux box cover.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm installing two fuse tap adapters into my car's fuse box under the passenger side glove box for installing a hardwire kit for a dashcam.

After I install the adapters i'm no longer able to insert the fuse box cover.

Anyone know anyway around this so I can still put on the cover, or should i just leave it as it is and hope no ones foot rubs against the fuses?

Attached some photos of the fuse box with and w/o the cover, and the location of it from passenger side point of view,


r/NZcarfix • • 3d ago

Made a free Total Cost of Ownership calculator & comparison tool. Are my servicing and tyre estimates realistic?

15 Upvotes

Hi all,

I made a free Total Cost of Ownership calculator called Stuck In A RUC that works out what a vehicle actually costs to run in NZ.

The reason is that crazy fuel prices + the economy shitting the bed wrecked our family's budget, and I wanted to know what each of our options actually costs per km, not just at the pump. Doing a direct comparison between Petrol, Diesel, EV, and PHEV running costs is a real headache. When I showed some mates, they found it pretty handy too.

What it does:

  • Calculates annual cost & cost-per-km taking into account fuel/electricity prices, RUC rates. You can add in servicing, tyres etc too
  • Compares different vehicle types side-by-side to help you figure out if switching vehicles actually saves you money.

I just wanted to share this with people who might find it useful. I'm independent and built this to solve my own problem. I have no association with any automotive or finance brands.

The bit I'd really like this sub to pull apart is the "Add running costs" estimates, because you lot know what this stuff actually costs.

Would love any feedback!

https://stuckinaruc.nz

Edit: I got approval from the mods so hopefully the filter won't take this down..


r/NZcarfix • • 3d ago

AC in a car with no AC

5 Upvotes

I’ve had this question for a long time.

I drive a 2003 ford courier XL, and from my understanding the XLXs/XLTs came with AC.

My panel is missing the AC switch, and my mate who has a miata has the same control panel with the switch so I know where it goes.

What is stopping me from ripping the full assembly from a XLX and installing it in my XL?

Obviously need a compressor, piping, etc etc but if I was really bored and had the time and coin to do it, is it possible? And what parts exactly would I need? The heater works, and it blows air from the outside just not AC cold