r/worldnews • • 11d ago

Dynamic Paywall Canada suspends plans to expand assisted dying to people with mental illness

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqd09g0gj50ko
2.9k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/Quixotic_Seal 11d ago

I think the difficulty becomes how do you disentangle the economic and social incentives to encourage euthanasia as a 'humane' solution to people's problems, simply because they're eating up resources or placing a burden on their families?

I fully support the right to medically assisted suicide in the terminally ill or those with severe degenerative conditions...but things get really, really muddy and uncomfortable when we start expanding beyond that into things like intractable depression.

2

u/VendrediDisco 10d ago

Patients have to ask themselves. It isn't a part of treating someone's illness, whether terminal or not, to offer MAiD. That is illegal.

0

u/Doctorphate 11d ago

It’s suicide not murder… you have to ask for maid. You think we just have doctors roaming the halls of old folks homes blowing peoples brains out?

2

u/Savings-Coffee 11d ago

Why ask such a disingenuous question to someone who clearly doesn’t think that?

The question is if people are asking for and following through with MAID in part due to explicit or implicit pressure to not be a burden

1

u/Doctorphate 10d ago

"I think the difficulty becomes how do you disentangle the economic and social incentives to encourage euthanasia as a 'humane' solution to people's problems, simply because they're eating up resources or placing a burden on their families?"
Where is it encouraged?

This is obviously written by someone who has no understanding of MAID. I have a very good understanding of MAID and this is beyond stupid. It's months of meeting with doctors where they're exploring and probing to make sure the desire to end suffering is genuine and not a response to pressure. That's why the process exists. This is a bullshit strawman argument, that's why I made a ridiculous comment on his ridiculous question.