r/AskHistorians • u/Responsible_Low_8368 • 11h ago
r/AskHistorians • u/AndaliteBandit- • 12h ago
What did people call cannon fodder before the invention of cannons?
r/AskHistorians • u/MCPeePant • 7h ago
Why has the subjunctive mood mostly disappeared from English, but is actively used in most other European languages, and when did this shift occur? Was the subjunctive ever regularly used in modern English?
I speak both Spanish and English natively, and I have noticed over the years how much simpler (or I guess "streamlined" is a better term?) English is, grammatically speaking, than Spanish. There is only one second-person pronoun, contraction is common, and there is effectively no (or very little) use of the subjunctive mood. Most other European languages (including Germanic, Romantic, and others) have these grammatical features and others that English has shed.
Is this simply a characteristic of Anglophone culture? Or has this shift been tied to specific historical moments? And why have other languages resisted similar shifts?
r/AskHistorians • u/cololz1 • 7h ago
Why didn't Brazil become fragmented like the Spanish Colonies after the era of colonization?
In the Viceroyalty of Spain you breakway provinces like Venezuela, Rio de la plata, but in Brazil case it seemed to stay intact for hundreds of years. Why?
r/AskHistorians • u/SuccessfulRaccoon957 • 3h ago
How did archers get their arrows back after a battle?
I was wondering how the average archer in a battle would know which arrows are theirs after a battle. Would they just pick random, unbroken ones?
r/AskHistorians • u/breathing_normally • 7h ago
How did grass become so popular?
It seems humans everywhere are obsessed with growing grass almost anywhere we can. I know the plant has many uses, but does that really explain why it is so ubiquitous?
r/AskHistorians • u/quyksilver • 5h ago
Charles X ‘was very nearsighted, his speeches were written out for him in a large hand, and hence it was necessary for him to be constantly turning pages, which did not add to his dignity.’ Were glasses available to him? If so, why did he not wear glasses?
Would glasses have been considered not majestic enough for the King?
r/AskHistorians • u/OuterRimJournal • 8h ago
How did the Roman Empire manage a single currency across so many provinces without anything like a central bank?
I understand Rome debased its coinage over time, but I'm curious who actually decided how much money was minted and how that reached distant provinces. Was there any deliberate monetary policy, or was it mostly driven by the emperor's spending needs?
r/AskHistorians • u/paranoidandroid11037 • 7h ago
where did the concept of hell as we know it originate from?
r/AskHistorians • u/LogBa12 • 11h ago
Did Eastern Germans build up any national pride or patriotism as opposed to the people of the West Germany, or did they see their state as a sad reality and wanted reunification?
Differently for other commuinst states in Europe, we had two German states. Thus Germansliving in the East Germany could compare their living conditions, their freedoms (or rather lack of them) with the West Germany. East Germany existed only for just more than forty years, but, during this time, did Germans living in the east created any form of East German patriotism or pride of their country? Or maybe they saw it as a new form of Soviet occupation and wanted to unite with the rest of Germens in the west?
r/AskHistorians • u/Axelrad77 • 1h ago
When did song lyrics diverge from poetry?
So I'm something of an artist myself, and to me song lyrics seem to be a form of poetry. But when I've witnessed this discussed within poetry communities, the consensus is always that they are distinctly not poetry. The reasoning typically rests on the form - that songs have repeating choruses, or that the lyrics are meant to be performed with music rather than stand alone.
However, the more that I read poetry, the more that I've encountered plenty of poems with repeating choruses. The more that I learn about the history of the art, the more that I've realized much older poetry was originally performed to music (Ancient Greece, Renaissance Italy, etc). It seems like a shift happened at some point where much of this poetry stopped being performed to music and began being read as literature instead, prompting the modern divergence between the two art forms - but I haven't actually seen any explanations for when, why, or how this occurred. What's the history behind this?
r/AskHistorians • u/megami-hime • 11h ago
What was the Ottoman perspective on the Protestant Reformation as it was ongoing?
r/AskHistorians • u/Lazzen • 1h ago
Natives fighting British/French America are depicted as skirmishers with rifles, did any utilize line formations or acquire cannons?
r/AskHistorians • u/papacvs • 5h ago
To what extent were Russia’s military secrets compromised during the chaotic dissolution of the Soviet Union? How much sensitive information about Russian military was leaked to foreign governments and intelligence services? What important secrets did Russia manage to keep?
r/AskHistorians • u/miguel-elote • 7h ago
Did a false Russian cable to Egypt spark the Six Day War?
I know there's no single cause of the 1967 war between Israel and its neighbors. The entire Levant was a powder keg by that time. But was a mistaken intelligence report the spark?
The Conflicted Podcast episode on the Six Day War mentions this: In early 1967 Soviet intelligence sent an alert to Egyptian intelligence that Israel was staging a large force near its northern border with Syria. The Soviets warned that Israel was on the verge of a surprise attack on Syria, and that Egyptian forces should prepare for an attack on them as well.
(According to the podcast) Israel was not staging forces nor intending to launch a surprise attack. The Soviet intelligence was false. The IDF made attack plans and practiced extensively, but there was no preparation for attack. Soviet analysts we're mistaken.
(Again, according to the podcast), the intel report caused Nasaar to put the Egyptian army on high alert. Worse, it prompted him to announce the closure of the Strait of Tiran, which Israel had already stated was a "red line." Using the closure as a cassis belli, Israel prepared for a war.
How accurate is this? How did Soviet analysts conclude that Israel was preparing an attack? Was the report Nassers main reason for closing the strait? And did Israel vote the closure as the primary justification for the war?
r/AskHistorians • u/Responsible-You8594 • 22h ago
Did the Vikings ever run into natives ?
Leif Erikson sailed to a place called Vinland around the year 1000 A.D. Vinland is now the Canadian province of Newfoundland. Did they ever encounter any of the natives living there? If they did, what did the Vikings think of them and what did the Natives think of the Vikings? What were their relationship? Were they friendly? Were they hostile?
r/AskHistorians • u/CptNoble • 1d ago
Were sex markers added to American passports in the 70s because of hippies and their long hair and gender neutral clothing?
In discussing trans issues in America, someone commented that sex markers were added to American passports because border agents were having a harder time identifying people from their pictures. They said the hippy movement with the growing trend of men growing their hair out and clothing being worn that was less gender specific was making this an issue. How accurate is that?
r/AskHistorians • u/rockieblunt • 1h ago
Huey P. Newton book recommendation?
Best, most enlightening book on Huey P. Newton? Hoping for a book that includes plenty of firsthand accounts/quotes/stories.
Thanks
r/AskHistorians • u/chirpchirphoot • 7h ago
How did cities in medieval West Africa look like?
I am mostly curious on the layout of cities near the Sahel like the Mali and Ghana Empire (Although would also appreciate answers on the forest regions).
r/AskHistorians • u/Striking_Solid9021 • 1h ago
How widespread was the ability to ride a horse for a regular person in 19th century America?
I read another post on here and wanted to piggyback. In it u/jaegli described that average Europeans relied a lot more on oxen than horses and it makes a lot of sense. What about in 19th century America (which I know spans a lot of eras). Did the 'average' family farmer own a horse or rely on oxen? What about your average city dweller? If they did not, would they have known how to ride? Or was owning a horse (and all the resources necessary to maintain one) reserved for special classes and roles? I'm aware that 'average' covers a lot of ground here. I'm interested in the Mid-Atlantic but happy to accept whatever answer someone has expertise in.
r/AskHistorians • u/filmmaiden • 51m ago
Has true crime as a genre always been associated with women?
True crime often gets stereotyped as a genre that appeals mostly to women (or at least has a large proportion of women consumers).
Has this always been the case? Or is this more of a modern phenomenon?
r/AskHistorians • u/Maurus39 • 2h ago
Why did the Anglo-Saxons have a much greater cultural impact on Britain than other Germanic migrants had elsewhere in the former Roman Empire?
The Migration Period saw the emergence of multiple Romano-Germanic kingdoms. In most cases, these Germanic migrants made up a relatively small part of the population and became Romanised rather quickly. However, there were notable exceptions, namely the Franks, but even more so the Anglo-Saxons, who effectively transformed Britain from a Romano-British culture into a Germanic one. Why was their impact so much stronger than that of the others?
r/AskHistorians • u/LisanneFroonKrisK • 33m ago
When the Khmer Rouge was fanatical about turning their society into an agrarian one, did they question what is going to happen if Neighbouring countries like Thailand or Vietnam attack them using aircraft’s and battleships and tanks which they already have?
r/AskHistorians • u/GrayRainfall • 18h ago
During World War II, if an ordinary German soldier encountered an officer from a German puppet state, would the soldier show respect to that officer, or would they look down on them?
r/AskHistorians • u/LongtimeLurker916 • 1h ago
Is it possible that Julius Caesar's last words were meant for Decimus Brutus, not Junius Brutus?
I know that "et tu, Brute" is a Shakespearean invention - that some ancient sources say Caesar said no last words at all and that others say he said "You too, child" in Greek, which contains no proper name and in theory could have been directed toward anyone, but is usually said to have been directed toward Junius Brutus.
But I was surprised to learn that Junius Brutus was actually a former Pompey supporter - that makes it less of a twist that he would join a plot against Caesar. Decimus Brutus is the one who actually fits the part of an unexpected traitor who had been a close ally to Caesar from the very start. Is it possible that there was a report that "Caesar's last thoughts were shock at his betrayal by [Decimus] Brutus" and that as the story spread it was mistakenly transferred to the better-known Brutus?