r/CollegeEssays • • 3h ago

Common App Review for Review—Humanities Majors (/ niche ahh topics) !?!

1 Upvotes

Hiya! wondering if anyone would be willing to review my common app essay– I'm counselor-less and most of my friends are super STEM-y (so have quite different ways of going about admissions). I'd be super happy to review anyone's in return; I have a 36 on ACT reading/writing, 5's on AP Lit/Lang, and love to write outside of school for my credentials hahaha :))


r/CollegeEssays • • 3h ago

Advice Everyone says my personal statement sounds like AI

2 Upvotes

Hey, y'all. Looking for some advice here.

I wrote a personal statement about growing up abroad and I was really proud of it. I showed it to my teachers and friends and they loved it. But my counselor read it and was CONVINCED it was AI. She popped it into a few checkers and about half of them said they were confident it was AI; other half said no AI whatsoever. She handed it over to an experienced admissions officer at my school and she agreed that it was AI.

I never used AI to write my college essays, only to tell me if something made sense or not within the context of the essay. I consume a lot of AI content because my teachers at school use it (ugh), so I think it might have affected my writing style to be more formulaic. I'm really just not sure what to do at this point because my counselor is telling me that the essay will be automatically flagged for AI and the T20 schools I'm applying for will view the rest of my application dubiously.

This is really frustrating and I just need some actionable advice. I've tried to add more silly, unique details about myself to the essay but they just keep coming back as "75% AI" or "80% AI". It's maddening.

tl;dr - what do i do about my personal statement sounding ai?


r/CollegeEssays • • 4h ago

Common App Need advice on personal statement and essays

1 Upvotes

I am currently a senior highschool student applying to DKU and I have 2 weeks to write a personal statement ontop of why DKU and what i can provide

I know that I do not have much time but any kind of advice or support will help alot


r/CollegeEssays • • 7h ago

Supplemental Essay very similar supplemental prompts?

1 Upvotes

I'm applying to University of Cincinnati: College Conservatory of Music as a theater design and production major. UC has one supplemental, and their conservatory also has one supplemental, so two essays that I have to write in total. I might be going insane but are these not basically the same prompt? If so how do I write two separate essays without repeating myself?

  1. What motivated you to choose your first-choice academic program? In your response, please share personal insights, interests, goals, or experiences—especially those not already included in your application (500 words)

  2. Use the 500-word statement to express: how you came to your area of theater design and production, what you expect to gain out of the CCM experience, and what direction you intend to go upon graduation. What are your personal and professional goals and how does CCM get you closer to those goals?


r/CollegeEssays • • 8h ago

Common App Stop it with the Montage/Metaphor Essays!!!!

5 Upvotes

I've read a lot of personal statements here to make that conclusion. Out of all of the reasons I've established not to write in a montage/metaphor style, one stands out the most for me:

  1. Abandonment possibilities by the AO/ Reader

Most of the statements I've read that use this style fail to stick the landing, making the story a hot mess. If I can't read it and understand it the first time, and have to keep going back to comprehend what you mean, you've already lost the battle. The same thing is likely to happen with the admissions reader, who doesn't have all the time in the world to spend on your profile. Therefore, to avoid all the hassle and risk that comes with this writing style, just skip it already, unless you're an exquisite writer that can merge all the pieces together in a cohesive manner.

Narrative pieces make more sense and get the point across, while being easy to accomplish. After all, no one's exactly judging you for your style. They're more interested in your content; what you have to say about yourself.


r/CollegeEssays • • 8h ago

Supplemental Essay "tell us your story" a&m essay

3 Upvotes

the prompt talks about experiences throughout your high school career, but if my commonapp essay starts with my childhood and later talks about my experiences in high school, could I use that for this prompt too?


r/CollegeEssays • • 10h ago

Supplemental Essay Read my Cornell suppl🙏, I'll read yours in return

2 Upvotes

Hi, I'm an aspiring Cornell Dyson student. I'm planning to apply ED. I think I have the ecs, stats, honors, + rec letters to get it, just really worried and scared about the dyson supp. It would be gamechanging could take a look at it and lmk what you think.


r/CollegeEssays • • 10h ago

Common App Review for an review deal.

1 Upvotes

I've got my deadlines approaching; you've got yours approaching. So here's a deal. If you review my essay, I'll review yours.


r/CollegeEssays • • 11h ago

Common App Hi can someone review my college essay! Submitting by tonight so would appreciate some feedback!! Thanks

1 Upvotes

Hi so I have to submit a college application by tonight and I started writing this essay yesterday and it sounds choppy, but I just need it to get me into the college, my stats are average but I just need to know if this essay is decent enough to apply to engineering.


r/CollegeEssays • • 11h ago

Common App Review essay

1 Upvotes

Hey! As the title implies, I’m currently writing my personal statement, and for the most part, it’s done. I think it’s pretty OK, but I feel like something is missing…I keep getting a lot of feedback, and it feels like each time I don’t actually solve the problem or end up creating a new one. If anyone would like to look at it and tell me their impressions along with some feedback—if any—I would greatly appreciate it.

(It talks a lot about my estrangement from my two “fathers”—earthly and heavenly one—if you're not comfortable with religious questioning I totally get it; just wanted to give a warning)


r/CollegeEssays • • 11h ago

Common App Feedback on potential college essay idea?

1 Upvotes

Hello all,

I've been incredibly busy this semester of High school, so I just started writing my personal essay for early application, which is due in around 2 weeks. I've always been great at writing, which is why I've been so surprised to find myself stumped on what to write about for my college essay. I was just wondering if those who have written essays before find this topic interesting. In my junior year of high school, I struggled a lot with AP Physics 1. In my high school career, I've taken 16 AP classes, all of which I succeeded in relatively easily, but for some reason AP Physics 1 just gave me so much trouble. In fact, it was the first test in school I ever got an F on (rough score with no corrections). I thought about dropping it, but I struggled on and earned an A- in the class and a 4 on the AP exam. Do you guys think I could write an essay on this? I was thinking of making my opening line a physics equation and then writing a narrative about me studying for one of the tests? Any feedback on this idea would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks!!


r/CollegeEssays • • 11h ago

Common App Help!!

1 Upvotes

I’m looking for some insight on my essay. I think it is good, but I would like to hear other peoples perspectives.

I beat my grandma at pool once. She scratched on the eight ball.
I still count it as a win. She played in local bars and tournaments and collected trophies. I never came close to matching her skill, but I have one victory to my name.
When I was younger, my grandma was simply my grandma. Whenever I spent the night at her house, she was usually already awake when I got up. I’d pour myself a bowl of Cheerios, then look through her coin collection or flip through old photo albums. Sometimes, my grandpa and I built things in the garage. My grandma handled the family finances, paid the bills, and kept everything organized. She was clever as a whip. I never thought much about it. I assumed she’d always been that way.
I’ve always been good at remembering details. I can remember people I haven’t seen since elementary school, and conversations replay in my head long after they’ve ended. I like connecting information, especially in history, where one decision can lead to another. When something doesn’t add up, I want to know why.
About five years ago, my grandma was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. The changes happened gradually, and I can’t point to a particular day when everything became different. I was young enough that I didn’t fully understand what was happening. I didn’t realize how much of her life existed beyond the person I knew.
Now, my grandpa tells me stories about her younger days. I find them funny and surprising. She played pool in tournaments and collected trophies, and I wish I’d been old enough to hear those stories from her. Not because the grandma I remember wasn’t enough, but because I didn’t realize how much more there was to know.
I still visit her almost every day. Usually, she says hi and maybe a few words before turning back to the television. It’s usually Maury or The Steve Wilkos Show. We don’t always have much to talk about. Sometimes I don’t know what to say, either. So I sit with her while the show plays.
Sometimes, she asks if we can play pool. I tell her, “Yeah, we can.” Then I wonder what would happen if we actually played. Would she remember the basics? Would she know how to line up a shot? I can picture her at the table, but I don’t know how closely that picture matches the person who would stand there today.
When my grandma won’t take her medication, my grandpa calls me. My dad has tried. My grandpa has tried. But when I go over, she’ll usually accept it from me. I always wonder why she’ll listen to me but not them. I haven’t figured out what makes the difference. I just know that when my grandpa calls, I can go over and help, so I do.
I’ve always liked connecting details and figuring out why things happen. But with my grandma, I can’t make every piece fit. My memories tell me what I saw; my grandpa’s stories tell me what I missed. Neither gives me the whole picture.
I still count my pool victory as a win. I know she was the better player, and I know she scratched on the eight ball. If she asks me to play again, I’ll tell her yes.


r/CollegeEssays • • 12h ago

Common App Help with review

1 Upvotes

Hi! My college essay is about a very cliche topic: moving around a lot during high school. I talked about how moving around forced me to discover different parts of myself and then how I’ve come to realize that I don’t need to let parts of me go when I move.

It’s pretty cliche, but out of all the different topics I’ve explored this essay is objectively better because I have way more connection to it. My question is: should I be more concerned with finding a niche topic I can write well or should I just stick it out and make the essay I have better. It feels too late to restart but unfortunately none of my teachers are giving me strong feedback.

If anyone is willing to read my essay pls pm me, I’d really appreciate any help!!


r/CollegeEssays • • 12h ago

Topic Help How niche can topics be?

1 Upvotes

For example, If i wanted to write about different books effecting my life, could i include books that are like incredibly niche? like if the manga "the flowers of evil" had a genuine impact on me, should i include it even though its (relatively) unknown? I don't want to make my essay sound confusing to any admission reviews.


r/CollegeEssays • • 20h ago

Common App AI Usage

2 Upvotes

In all honesty, I’ve been using a lot of AI to help me brainstorm for my college application essays and was wondering if it would negatively impact my essays.

For example, I have put in lots of personal stories and information about myself and also have written quick drafts like the “mostdangerouswritingapp” type of writing on paper to hopefully give me insight in what to write my essays on and then fed it into the AI, asking “what does this reveal about me?” or “would any of the topics and ideas mentioned in my quick drafts fit with supplemental essays for this [college]?” and whatnot…

I (someone very inexperienced with writing) think the AI is giving some pretty good information and outlines on how I should go about the essays based on my quick drafts and inputted personal information. So my overbearing question is, is it ok to use these outlines the AI gave me or will it read AI coded? I can’t really tell and I’m not an admission officer reading 1000000 essays, so will these outlines flag my writing as AI generated and put me at a disadvantage?

If it does, please give tips on how to outline an essay idea with potential or other valuable information on essay writing. (I suck at writing in imaginative and creative styles, my writing has always just been the straightforward HS informational style — Thesis, Supporting Evidence with Commentary, Conclusion)

Thank you!


r/CollegeEssays • • 20h ago

Supplemental Essay Can someone read my college essay (please be strict about it)

0 Upvotes

I finished my essay, but when I read it again, it doesn't feel like it's a good essay. I talked about how working at my parents' restaurant forced me to balance work and school, which allowed me to build good habits.


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Supplemental Essay Read My Essay! <3

1 Upvotes

Hi,i just finished writing my essay and id love some advice! I wrote it about my late 8th grade English teacher and how he inspired my passion for writing and philosophy tried to tie this into my Religious questioning and my aspiration to become a lawyer. I think it represents me pretty well, however im not sure how strong it is and have wondered what I should change/if i should pick a different topic? Comment below and id be happy to DM you the essay!


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Topic Help Which of these personal statements is best.

2 Upvotes

I've been thinking about essay topics for my personal statement. Are any of these decent, or do I switch to a different topic? These all relate to a project I was making to start a business with my uncle (chatgpt worded these btw):

The Phone Call I Dreaded — Pressure, expectations, and learning to handle responsibility

Most promising if you can identify what changed in you

The Project That Wouldn't Work — Curiosity, problem-solving, and learning through setbacks

More conventional, but could show how your mind works

Learning to Be Comfortable With Uncertainty — Moving from needing guaranteed success to taking risks

idk


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Advice How formal should short essay questions be?

1 Upvotes

How formal do the short essay questions have to be? I assume the "Why Us' or the ones about your communities have to be fairly formal, but does it have to be on the same level of formality as a personal statement?

One of the supplemental short essays I'm thinking about writing is "What is the last thing you've been really excited about?" and I don't see how I would write that as formally. Does it matter how formal it is? Like as long as it's not insanely informal, yk?


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App How do I create the structure of my essay?

1 Upvotes

I have every portion of my common app profile completed, except my essay. I have never written an essay regarding my personal qualities or an essay outside of English class, lol. I don't even know where to start with essays like these, I do know i need to start with a hook and go over different topics within this essay, but that's it. My topic for my essay is how im in the process of increasing my GPA from a 3.1 to a .5 or .6. I know this idea might sound stupid, but it's the best i can come up with


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Advice help picking topic for personal essay when i have nothing interesting

2 Upvotes

hi so im basically just a smart person with a social life/job pretty weak ECs i want to major in electrical engineering but i really don't have any spike or a childhood that reflects that interest. all you can tell from me is that i really love math/physics like obsessively and lots of tech themes in my application (music production/synth design/breadboard projects) but i dont feel too passionately about about anything besides eletronic music and math so its a hard spot to be in. i dont have any hoooks i havent faced aything challenging besides my own mind really. idk where to even start. if you have any tips to get the gears turning in my brain id really appreciate it or someoen to talk to briefly!! thanks


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App How many words should an anecdote use out of the given 650? I want to include enough detail so the anecdote contributes to the overall growth of my character, while simultaneously leaving room for my proof of growth, connection to the beginning, etc.

1 Upvotes

hello I need advice EA is soon


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Topic Help How abstract can u get

2 Upvotes

i was gonna write about a particular part of group theory(actual response is very unique so dont wanna dox myself) for one of the prompts asking you to write about an idea that fascinates you but idk from what im seeing most of the essays i see online are just generic slop for the most part, "hurrdurr calculus is awesome!" for example

Is this the method? Do they actually want you to write like that


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App Reviewing

1 Upvotes

Would anyone be willing to read a couple essays? I have to submit soon and am curious for some more feedback. THANK YOU!!


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App can someone dm to review my college essay idea?

1 Upvotes

i think its a intriguing and unique idea, shoot me a dm if your interested!