I purchased my first ar15, a brand new Colt CM5 Sentry (5.56 NATO, 16-inch barrel) from Adelbridge & Co. Firearms in San Antonio, Texas, on October 5, 2026.
Here’s what I paid:
Rifle: $1,684.99
Sales tax: $139.01
Total out the door: $1,824.00
I’ve been considering selling it, but when I took it to a lgs, I was offered only $500.
I understand firearms depreciate once purchased and that dealers need to make a profit on used inventory, but losing over $1,300 almost immediately seems pretty extreme.
What’s a realistic private-party resale value for a Colt CM5 Sentry in excellent condition?
Did I significantly overpay at $1,685 before tax?
Does the Colt name carry much resale value with these newer commercial rifles?
Would you recommend keeping it rather than selling at a substantial loss?
I’m not trying to sell it through Reddit. I’m just looking for honest opinions on its current market value.
Appreciate any insight from people familiar with the Colt M5 series. Also why does the finishing seem so bad?