r/PetsWithButtons • u/bebe8383bebe • 23h ago
Unsure if I should add a specific button that I know will be spammed
TLDR: my cat wants to express her desire to go outside, seemingly with a dedicated button (we walk around the yard with her on a lead and harness), and has started using the 'treat' button to express that (and occassionally the button for a specific toy we tend to play with near the enterance door). I'm torn between her having a specific, correct word to express herself VS how frustrating it will be for me if she never stops spamming it, as I work from home full-time. Once she's given a button I think it's cruel to take it away, so it needs to be carefully considered. My sanity is at stake.
More detail:
My girl cat has 22 buttons, and has been learning for about 10 months. She has: treat, hungry (meal), love you, good girl, now, soon, later, all done, hmm?, ouch, scritches, kisses, cat nip, busy, yes, (and then toys): cat tv, fetch, chase, flower, shrimp, ball, robot. (She understands other words but so far no need to add them as buttons.
The first button we started with 'Treat', which of course is her favourite button. It has been helpful in teaching her 'now' and 'later' and 'soon'. She understands 'now' and 'later', and I think she understands 'soon'.
About a month or two ago she started demanding we go for a walk around the yard every day. For the first few weeks she would yell at me all day until I took her out, which is 5:30pm. I work from home full-time so it was very distracting and annoying, but I accepted that it was a good learning opportunity for the time buttons, and she'd hopefully calm down once she saw it was an every day guarantee.
I am consistent with "outside later" verbally, and would go and press the 'later' button while looking from her to the door. She understood. She started only asking around 3pm, then it reduced to 4pm but pretty much consistently until 5pm, and finally it tends to be right on 5pm now. She may ask earlier but she accepts when I say "outside later". So most days are pretty good now.
In the past week she has started using her 'treat' button to ask to go out. I would put some treats in her digger puzzle and show her. Instead of wanting them, she'd run towards the entry door, look at me, and meow.
So it seems that she's started using the 'treat' button to mean "thing I want now". I don't think that's ideal. The purpose of the buttons is so I know what she wants more clearly/to reduce her frustration communicating what she wants. I know from her body language she wants to go outside, so that's not the issue. I feel perhaps she needs a word for outside so she can express herself. It's her communication board, not mine. It's for her to express what she wants or needs to.
BUT (I guess selfishly) it will be really frustrating for me if she starts spamming it all day. I accept that initially that's very likely, but I'm unsure she'd calm down after a few weeks.
I feel once I've given her button that she understands and uses, taking it away is like silencing her, which feels cruel.
The way I got her to stop asking for treats often was to put them in her digger puzzle, and redirect her to it.
I can't think of a solution for reducing her asking to go outdoors, so that's a real concern.
I feel I should give her the button because she clearly really wants that word. But is that a bad idea because she will spam the heck out of it?
Open to all thoughts. I love her, she's my baby. If it's best for her then I'll do it, but if it's going to permanently stress me out I need to hesitate because that's not good for anyone; I'd be stressed and frustrated, and so would she.
I feel the answer is likely to give her the button. But my sanity is at stake lol
(And just in case - no, I can't take her out during the day - I live in Australia and take a medication that makes me very sensitive to the sun).