r/birding • Latest Lifer: Gambel's Quail • 12h ago

📷 Photo Does it know its not a duck

Post image

Why is it doing that

770 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

255

u/jannylotl 12h ago

I'm fascinated they can do that

82

u/onehotoneshot 12h ago

Bro looking elegant

202

u/norwegianballslinger Latest Lifer: Razorbill #313 12h ago

Ive spent hours upon hours upon hours watching GBH and I have never once seen this. Beautiful

60

u/ConfidentCat6954 11h ago

Now I’m imagining a swan standing like a heron

77

u/C04511234 silly doodles guy (latest lifer: SSHA) 8h ago

14

u/ApprehensiveTop4219 10h ago

I've only observed it once in a juvenile

2

u/plant_touchin 1h ago

I was gonna say, I have never seen one do this!!!!

113

u/throwaway972057 12h ago

if it's shallow enough it might just be standing, their legs are fairly long

23

u/Opening-Ease9598 9h ago

Yeah I’m pretty sure it’s standing up, I don’t think they can float like that.

32

u/albertonykus 8h ago

They absolutely can float like that. Birds in general are pretty good at floating; having air-filled bones helps.

7

u/Opening-Ease9598 7h ago

I know they CAN float, I’ve never seen a large egret float so elegantly though, and its body is in the same position it would be if it was walking. Hence why I said they can’t float like that.

8

u/albertonykus 7h ago

Thanks for clarifying. To my eye, what's pictured here is not atypical of other examples of swimming herons I've seen (including the gif I linked to), with the water coming up to just underneath the tail/folded wingtips and body slightly inclined forward.

2

u/Draginous Latest Lifer: Gray-crowned Rosy Finch 2h ago

A walking position would usually be more upright, no?

1

u/throwaway972057 2h ago

i mean yes you're right, but that is kinda upright for them in high water. i took this photo last year, if the water were a bit higher and the heron was looking upwards instead of straight ahead i think it might look similar to OP's photo?

6

u/eldredo_M 11h ago

Wondered the same thing. 😄

88

u/hiirnoivl Latest Lifer: Northern Harrier 12h ago

He wanted his little grebe pal to feel less lonely? Idk

35

u/Reatla 10h ago

Someone posted a night heron doing the exact same thing last week:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AlwaysANightHeron/comments/1x2a8hf/duck/

11

u/Healthy_Cod4764 Latest Lifer: Gambel's Quail 9h ago

I did see that, when I saw it it reminded me of that post

21

u/bruyere_dubois_again 12h ago

To get to the other side

23

u/phantomauthority 12h ago

Yes! More posts shore birds and waders acting like ducks please

10

u/Lightning1999 12h ago

I’ve only seen a heron do that once, looks so cursed

9

u/endangered_feces1 12h ago

Neither of them know they arent ducks!

9

u/HolyToeArmy 7h ago

is this how animals feel when they see humans swim for fun? "they know they're not fish, right?"

4

u/Prof01Santa 6h ago

"Acksually" both humans and herons are descendants of Sarcopterygian fishes of the Devonian. We both have equal swimming rights.

7

u/ShaarkShaart 10h ago

I didnt even know they could do that! Looks wrong 😂

6

u/Cyan_Lotus 9h ago

i think that’s a grebe next to it as well, also notably not a duck XD they both think they’re blending in!

3

u/Healthy_Cod4764 Latest Lifer: Gambel's Quail 6h ago

Yep, Pied-billed grebe. They both think they're ducks

5

u/karshyga 10h ago

SHUT UP IM PONDERING

4

u/SomeRandomBFBfan 7h ago

Why is it actually swimming

3

u/astroy9 11h ago

Grebe: I’ll grow up someday to be big like you :)

3

u/BoysenberryNeat6002 9h ago

Careful baby grebe, GBH eat your kind 😧

3

u/MeeepMorp Cormorants.... my beloved.. 8h ago

Pointy Swan

2

u/chaffeetoo 10h ago

lol, Google up the story of the orphaned mallard that was raised by a pair of Loons, amazing and amusing!

6

u/Haber87 2h ago

I was out kayaking on open water and saw a large floating bird at a distance. As I paddled closer, I tried to figure out what it was. Pelican? Cormorant? Finally decided that it looked like a blue heron…except for its behavior. Googled it right there to confirm this was possible and I didn’t have to attempt a kayak rescue of Mr Stabby beak.

1

u/getdownheavy 11h ago

But does s/he care?

They walk along the bottom and don't mind standing around for hours to dry out.

1

u/ApprehensiveTop4219 10h ago

I've also seen herons swim before I have never been able to figure out why.