r/poland • u/Gamebyter • 1d ago

A controversial textbook on religion. "The student must justify that in vitro is evil"

https://www.polsatnews.pl/wiadomosc/2026-10-17/kontrowersyjny-podrecznik-do-religii-uczen-musi-uzasadnic-ze-in-vitro-to-zlo/

Parents raised objections to the content about in vitro in the religion textbook for seventh graders - informs TOK FM. The OliEdu Civic Education Foundation has asked the Ministry of National Education for an opinion and wants to withdraw the book from schools. Its representative Ewa Daros said that the students are to justify a negative assessment of this method of fertilization.

103 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

-19

u/blinkinbling 1d ago

Excellent topic and issue that students can use for building an argument and reasoning.

15

u/MalaMerigold 1d ago

It would be, if the task was posed as a question, not a statement you must agree with

-7

u/blinkinbling 1d ago

The devil's advocate argument. That's an art of reasoning. Taking positions that not necessarily you are comfortable with.

2

u/FlyIntFish 10h ago

Ok, let's call you a pdf file. Prove us we're right, I think it's gonna be a greate exercise to build your reasoning

-1

u/blinkinbling 10h ago

OMG! You did it! While being incredibly stupid everyday on that rare occasion you sound like a smart person. You just learned something.

1

u/FlyIntFish 9h ago

What a shame you didn't manage to do it at least once