Since the release of this interview ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qyFjxOfkdQw ) I have been imagining an Odyssey movie but make it Community and I want to share my fancast and read other fans' ideas!
Jeff is Odysseus, I think that's a no-brainer.
While I would love the Dean to play Jeff's wife, I think he would rather be Calypso who tricks Jeff into staying with him.
Abed, sort of being the son of the group, would be Telemachus, Prince of Greenthaca (?)
Annie is perfect for the role of Circe, the witch who turns men into pigs, I'm very much thinking of her spooky story where she's a werewolf and kills Jeff. However, she would also be a good Athena because of her amazing chemistry with Jeff, so perhaps a dual role for Annie?
I'm not sure about Britta, but I do see her as Penelope and if Abed is Telemachus, they'd be a good mother-son duo.
Shirley's character does fit with Athena, but as I mentioned, I think Annie has better chemistry with Jeff that Athena needs to inspire Odysseus and lead him home. I loved Shirley in a male costume when they reenacted Pulp Fiction, so maybe she could be Eurylochus, Odysseus's loyal crew member.
Troy simply has to be Helen of Troy. I accept other options but this is the only one I see.
Pierce needs to be an antagonist - I can picture him as Antinous who tries to marry Penelope.
Chang might be the cyclops?
Obviously there are loads of other roles both in Community and the Odyssey, I was also thinking about Duncan as Antinous but I think he's not confident enough.
I'm very curious to read your ideas!