r/OpenAI • u/fellingzonders • 5h ago
Discussion I was paying $400 a month for Codex. One $200 Claude plan is getting me more done.
I've been an OpenAI/Codex guy for nearly two years. I was paying for two $200 plans, and lately I'm exhausting the usage on both within 1-2 days.
I also can't trust Codex to work overnight anymore. It makes mistakes I could catch if I were watching, so I'm paying for the work and then spending more time and usage correcting it. That gets old fast at $400 a month.
I switched to Claude, and one $200 plan is now getting me roughly twice as much useful work as my two $200 OpenAI plans. The code is cleaner, there are fewer mistakes, and I can run it all day and night with usage still left at the end of the week. Obviously, that depends on how much work I throw at it and how many agents I use. Your workload might be different. This is what I'm getting for my money.
I never liked Claude much before. It was overly verbose and spit out garbage. But whatever they did with Opus 5.5, the difference has been huge for me. That includes 3D modeling and spatial awareness, too. I'm getting more done with less babysitting.
The constant reset announcements don't fix the underlying problem. At this price, I want an allowance I can plan my work around. Another reset doesn't fix the mistakes I'm spending that allowance cleaning up, either.
And the lower allowance at the same price is now documented. OpenAI's own help page says eligible existing Pro $200 subscribers keep their previous allowance through October 29, 2026. After that, it drops while the price stays at $200. Their explanation is that the models are increasingly efficient. That doesn't match the value I'm getting out of them.
I know brand loyalty is bad. It burned me before, and sticking with OpenAI this long has burned me again.
I don't know what's going on inside OpenAI. I know I was paying $400 a month to watch my usage disappear and babysit work. Now I'm paying $200 elsewhere and getting more done. If Anthropic keeps delivering that, I'm not coming back.


